My First Time: A Love Story

My first time happened at an AmeriSuites, a mid-range hotel chain that has been bought out by Hyatt and no longer exists. My church youth group was visiting the mountains. This was a stop on our way home.

I was thirteen. I remember the room, the highway outside the window, the sound of cars. I was randomly paired in bed with a boy who was a few years older than me. I didn’t know his name. He had bright blue eyes and went to my school.

In the night, he brushed his hand over my cock and I got hard. Then he put his hand in my underwear. Then he pulled my hand to his body and placed my fingers just inside the brim of his boxers. I moved my fingers forward, felt curly hair below them, then touched another man’s cock for the first time.

When the whole thing was finished, I panicked, faked a nightmare, and started talking out loud so he’d think I did it all asleep — I repeated the only name I could think of, “J.K.,” the name of a guy I had sexual tension with at camp the summer before. I’m not sure he believed it, but he woke me up and said I was talking in my sleep.

The next day, there were snickers and taunts in the back of the bus where he and other older boys were sitting. One guy, seemingly on a dare, came up to me and said, “Hey, can I rub you?” I assume he told the other boys that I had touched him. I sat alone on the bus all the way home, saying nothing.

I later learned his name: William. He left my school not long after this to attend a more expensive school an hour away. I only saw him once again, several years later. My family had started attending a megachurch in Athens. One day we were leaving the service when someone called my father’s name. Dad turned and spoke to a man he recognized. The auditorium was dark. Christian pop blasted out of the speakers. I was looking the other way when Dad put his hand on my shoulder and said, “This is my son, Alex.”

I turned and shook the man’s hand. The man said to me, “You probably remember my son. He used to go to your school.”

The son was standing behind him. I shook the son’s hand. As I did, I realized I had touched this hand before. It surprises me now that in my introductory experience, I did not make the first move. On the contrary, I was pulled, guided, trembling, along the surface of the sheet in darkness and silence.

The cock? I don’t know, and it doesn’t matter. Big, small, I can’t remember. It was a cock. It was hard. It was God. But my memory doesn’t care about the dick and I don’t remember it. I remember the heat of his body, his legs, the hair on his skin, the way we slid closer, spooned, attempted to push our dicks in each other dryly, having no idea what we were doing. It’s almost comical and very perfect. The complicity of it, the way we moved with no instruction, the way we did what we were meant to do — it was so pure. We were machines doing what we were designed for. And somehow all this happened with other boys asleep in the room with us.

In the megachurch, people filed out around us. The handshake lasted for half a second, however long handshakes last, then Dad said goodbye and we left. I’m sure my family fussed over where to go for lunch. I’m sure I played along. But a fire burst there inside me, the kind of burning hunger that every gay man in the closet experiences. It haunts you and you carry it around, aching, killing you, suffocating you. I looked for him every Sunday after that and never found him again.

Last I heard, he was dating a girl at the school he transferred to. He became MVP on the football team there. I don’t know if he went to college or where he lives now. I don’t know if he’s happy. I don’t know if he’s come out or even how he identifies. But I do know that he still describes himself on Facebook as a straight man, or at least makes no indication that he is gay. I could reach out to him, but what would I say? What did we share? It was a few moments of heat, nothing more. But it birthed me. It might have meant nothing to him, but it was my life, delivered in a discreet fumbling under the covers of a hotel room bed. I could fall at his feet and kiss them. My deliverer, my savior. He could be replaced by any other boy — the hotel could be switched with any other, the night any other, and I would still be what I am now — but he was the one who touched me, of all things, and unlocked an animal.

My brother, if you’re reading this, thank you. What we did wasn’t revelatory. What lingered in my body was not the action but its residue — after I got off the bus, met my parents at the car, and was carried home. When I walked in the house, I was something new. The many silences that followed, the nights lying awake, the daydreams, everything: you are in all of them. In such innocent, discreet groping, you confirmed in me something I was not yet ready to name. That’s all it took — touching you.

If you’re gay and still living in the closet, the only advice I can offer is this: no one will save you. You must be willing to destroy everything in your life in order to live. You have to do it. You have to claw your way out.

Love, Beastly 

Please consider being a monthly supporter on Patreon!

1 Comment

  1. This post caught me in a moment of retrospection….
    I still think of the night I lost my virginity with “Give it away now” by The Red Hot Chili Peppers softly playing on the TV in front of us.
    The thought of that night still brings me visions blurry with desire and wonder.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s